Should You Refinance Your Mortgage? Costs and Tradeoffs

Summary:

If you’re asking, “Should I refinance my mortgage?” a lower interest rate is only part of the answer. This guide walks through the key tradeoffs to consider before refinancing, including how to compare Loan Estimates, calculate your break-even point, evaluate cash-out options and understand when a lower monthly payment could cost you more over time.

Decide whether to explore refinancing

Start with what you're trying to accomplish. It may make sense to refinance if you want to:

  • Lower your monthly mortgage payment
  • Pay off your mortgage loan sooner
  • Move from an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) to a fixed-rate mortgage
  • Change the length of your loan term
  • Access home equity through cash-out refinancing
  • Remove or change a borrower when permitted by the new loan program
A married couple look at documents while the toddler draws on them
A married couple look at documents while the toddler draws on them

Pause before refinancing if you:

  • Expect to sell or move before payment savings offset closing costs
  • Would restart with a much longer loan term
  • Have a prepayment penalty
  • Have not compared Loan Estimates from different lenders
  • Are considering a cash-out refinance without a clear purpose for the funds

Your goal drives which type of refinance to consider and which terms to compare. It also changes what counts as a good offer. A lower monthly payment can come from a lower interest rate, a longer loan term or both—and those two routes cost very different amounts over the loan’s lifetime. If you don't know which one you're being offered, you don't yet know what the offer is worth.

Check your current mortgage and qualification before applying

A refinance requires underwriting for a new mortgage. Your credit, income, assets, debts, home value, property details and current mortgage balance can affect whether you qualify and the terms you receive.

Pull together:

  • Your current mortgage loan statement
  • Your Note and any Addendum to the Note
  • Recent income documentation
  • Asset documentation
  • Information about monthly debts
  • An estimate of your home’s current value
  • Your expected time in the home
  • Your current mortgage payment and remaining balance

Your home value and mortgage balance can affect your available equity. A lender may also require an appraisal or another property valuation review as part of the refinance process.

Read your loan documents for a prepayment penalty. A prepayment penalty can require you to pay additional money if you refinance or otherwise pay off the mortgage early,¹ and it can change the math on an otherwise reasonable refinance.

Choose between a no cash-out refinance and cash-out refinance

No cash-out refinance

A no cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage without providing you with cash beyond permitted amounts. The new mortgage may include permitted transaction costs.

It may fit if your goal is to:

  • Reduce your interest rate
  • Change from an adjustable-rate mortgage to a conventional loan
  • Shorten or lengthen the loan term
  • Lower the monthly payment without borrowing additional funds

Cash-out refinance

A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage loan with a larger mortgage and provides cash from your home equity. Because your home secures the new mortgage, both the higher balance and the purpose of the funds deserve real scrutiny.²

People use cash-out refinances for home improvements, major expenses or debt consolidation. However, using home equity to pay personal debt converts unsecured or shorter-term debt into mortgage debt secured by your home³ and should be considered only after careful consideration.

Before choosing cash-out refinancing, ask:

  • How much will the new mortgage balance increase?
  • Will the new monthly payment fit your budget?
  • Does the purpose of the cash justify borrowing against your home?
  • Would keeping your current mortgage and using another financing option better meet your goal?

Compare the full cost, not just the interest rate

Once you know your goal and mortgage refinance type, compare offers with matching loan terms. An advertised interest rate alone does not show whether an offer is the best fit.

Lenders may quote similar interest rates but charge different points, lender fees, or closing costs. Another lender may offer lower upfront costs but a higher interest rate or monthly payment. Both can look competitive in an ad.

Request Loan Estimates for the same loan type, loan amount, loan term, points or lender credits and rate-lock status when applicable. Matching those inputs makes differences in costs and risks easier to identify.¹

Review the mortgage rate and payment

On each Loan Estimate, check the interest rate, the monthly principal and interest payment, the loan term, whether the payment can change and whether the rate is locked.

Review upfront costs

Then check the points, origination charges, lender credits, total loan costs, prepaid items, initial escrow payment and cash to close. An initial escrow payment is money collected to establish or replenish an escrow account for things like property taxes and homeowners insurance. It isn't a lender fee, but it is cash you have to bring.

A no-closing-cost refinance isn’t necessarily free. The lender may cover upfront costs through lender credits tied to higher interest fees or add closing costs to the loan amount. Higher-rate lender credits and financed closing costs can increase your cost over time or reduce your equity.⁴

Review the longer-term comparison

Look at the "In 5 years" comparison on the Loan Estimate. It shows what each offer costs over a period long enough for the differences to surface.

Before closing, review the Closing Disclosure and compare its final terms and costs against the Loan Estimate.

Calculate your break-even point

For a mortgage refinance aimed at lowering your payment, the break-even point estimates how long it will take for monthly savings to recover what the refinance cost.

Break-even point = refinance costs ÷ monthly mortgage payment savings

Say the refinance costs $4,200 and drops your payment by $180 a month. Dividing one by the other puts break-even a little past 23 months. If you're planning to make a move in two years, the refinance roughly breaks even and does nothing else for you. If you're staying ten, the picture is entirely different.

Compare the cash you'll pay at closing against the amount your monthly payment would drop. The result tells you how long you need to keep the new mortgage before the savings cover the cost.

Break-even is a narrow measure. It tracks the recovery of upfront costs through payment savings. Still, it doesn’t necessarily show total interest paid, the equity effects of increased or decreased home values or whether the new loan term is a good idea. Break-even analysis is less useful on its own when you are:

  • Taking cash out
  • Shortening the loan term
  • Rolling closing costs into the new mortgage balance
  • Changing from an adjustable-rate mortgage to a fixed-rate mortgage
  • Refinancing primarily for payment stability rather than payment savings

A lower payment can still cost more over time

A lower monthly payment does not always mean a lower-cost mortgage.

If you’ve already paid down your current mortgage and refinance into a new, longer loan term, you may reduce the payment while extending the time you’re repaying the loan. You can end up paying more total interest than if you had left the original loan alone.

When you review an offer, put these numbers side by side:

  • Your remaining term on the current mortgage
  • The term of the new mortgage
  • Your current monthly payment
  • The proposed monthly payment
  • The total amount financed
  • The total interest you’d pay if you keep each loan through its term

That last line will help settle the evaluation. If paying off the mortgage sooner is the priority, a shorter term matters more than the lowest available payment. If payment flexibility is the priority, a longer term can be the right call—as long as you've seen the total interest figure and decided it's worth it.

When refinancing may not make sense

Some of these are dealbreakers, and some are just cautions, but each is a reason to slow down:

  • You expect to sell or move before you’d recover the closing costs
  • Your payment decreases mainly because the new loan term is much longer
  • The new mortgage doesn’t improve your overall financial position after costs
  • You’re taking cash out for a purpose that does not justify increasing mortgage debt
  • Your current mortgage has favorable terms that the new mortgage would replace
  • You haven’t compared Loan Estimates from different lenders

None of these rules out a refinance on its own. A homeowner moving in four years can still come out ahead if the savings are large enough. Weigh your expected time in the home, total cost, payment and loan term together rather than disqualifying an offer based on any single factor.

Ready to explore your refinancing options?

Refinancing is worth exploring when the new mortgage supports a specific financial goal and improves your position after you account for the full cost.

Request Loan Estimates using the same requested loan terms. Then compare the interest rate, points, lender fees, lender credits, cash to close, monthly payment, loan term and total cost. A careful comparison can help you choose a mortgage that fits both your current budget and your longer-term plans.

To make the most informed decision, it’s always a good idea to consult with trusted lenders or financial advisors before potentially incurring unnecessary risks. Schedule time with an Associated Bank mortgage professional to discuss your refinancing goals, compare available mortgage options and understand the potential costs and tradeoffs before you decide. A conversation can help you determine whether refinancing makes sense for you and what your next steps may look like.

Key takeaways

  • Refinancing could make sense when the new mortgage supports a specific goal after you consider its full cost.

  • Compare Loan Estimates for the same loan type, loan amount, loan term, points or lender credits and mortgage rate-lock status.

  • A lower monthly payment can result from a longer loan term, which may increase total interest paid.

  • A cash-out refinance increases mortgage debt secured by your home, so consider the purpose of the cash carefully.

  • Your expected time in the home matters because payment savings may need time to offset refinance costs.

Refinancing replaces your current mortgage with a new mortgage. It may make sense when the new mortgage supports a specific goal, such as lowering your monthly payment, paying off your mortgage sooner, changing your loan type or accessing equity.

A lower interest rate can help, but it does not answer the full question. Your loan term, closing costs, cash to close, monthly mortgage payment and total interest can all affect whether refinancing improves your financial position.

Refinancing Your Mortgage Frequently Asked Questions

No. There's no single rate difference that would make refinancing right for every home owner, despite how often you'll hear a specific number quoted. Compare the interest rate, closing costs, loan term, monthly payment, total interest and how long you expect to stay in the home.

Usually not. The lender may charge a higher interest rate, provide lender credits that change the pricing, or add the costs to your loan amount. As noted above, review the Loan Estimate to see the full cost.

Yes, and it's common. Refinancing into a longer loan term reduces the monthly payment while extending how long you pay interest. Compare your remaining term against the new term before you decide. Make sure to use the breakeven calculation referenced above to help with your decision.

Closing costs are charges associated with obtaining the new mortgage. Cash to close is what you actually bring to the table, after closing costs, prepaid items, the initial escrow payment, lender credits and other transaction details are accounted for. Both appear on the Loan Estimate, and they're rarely the same number.



Sources
1. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/compare/review-loan-estimates/
2. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/cash-out-refinances-and-paydown-behavior-of-non-mortgage-debt-balances/
3. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/archive/newsroom/cfpb-report-finds-cash-out-mortgage-refinance-borrowers-improve-credit-scores/
4. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/is-there-such-a-thing-as-a-no-cost-or-no-closing-loan-or-refinancing-en-141/

  • Loan products are offered by Associated Bank, N.A., and are subject to credit approval and involve interest and other costs. Please ask about details on fees and terms and conditions of these products. Property insurance and flood insurance, if applicable, will be required on collateral. (1050)