How to Protect Your Business From Fraud

Summary:

Business fraud can take many forms, from fake invoices and phishing scams to unauthorized payments and employee misconduct. For small businesses, even a single incident can lead to significant financial losses and operational disruptions. The good news is that proactive fraud prevention measures can help reduce these risks. By strengthening payment controls, securing sensitive information and educating employees, business owners can better protect their finances and operations. Here are the key steps every business should take to help prevent fraud.

Fraud is more prevalent than ever, according to Hillary Combs-Orgeman, Bank Relationship Manager at Associated Bank. With the 2025 National Retail Federation reporting a 70% increase in phone scams and a 55% increase in digital and ecommerce fraud,¹ protecting your business on multiple fronts is more than proactive, it’s necessary.

Protecting your business from fraud starts with clear rules for moving money and sharing sensitive information. Independently confirm payment changes, separate payment preparation from approval, restrict account access and assign someone to investigate unfamiliar activity. The Association for Financial Professionals recommends independent verification, segregation of duties and payment monitoring as complementary controls.²

The steps below will help safeguard your business from future threats.

Where to start: Assign responsibility 

Use this worksheet to identify gaps in your current financial fraud mitigation process. Give each task an owner and a backup, and record what still needs to change.

Area to reviewAction to assignSuggested owner
Payment instructionsDocument how staff confirm new or changed recipient details.Owner or finance manager
Account visibilityRoute bank alerts to someone authorized to investigate.Finance manager
AccessReview permissions for banking, email, payroll and accounting systems.System administrator with the owner
Banking servicesRequest a demonstration of available controls and exception handling.Finance manager with the bank
Independent oversightArrange payment review and account reconciliation outside the payment preparer’s duties.Owner with the accountant
Incident responseStore verified emergency contacts where staff can reach them if email is unavailable.Owner with the IT provider

Bring your actual workflow to discussions with your bank and accountant. Include vendor setup, payroll changes, customer refunds and what happens when the usual approver is away.

Recognize the fraud risks in your workflow

Fake invoices, government impersonation and unsolicited technical support are established business scams. The Federal Trade Commission’s Scams and Your Small Business: A Guide for Business describes these tactics and the pressure scammers use to rush decisions.

Give staff a way to pause suspicious requests or phishing emails. Treat an unexpected licensing demand, utility disconnection threat or computer-security pop-up as a reason to contact the relevant organization independently.

In fact, Associated Bank’s free Bank at Work program is designed to empower employees and owners. “It gives your employees access to financial literacy, including how to safeguard their accounts, how to protect themselves from fraud, how to protect themselves from identity theft and a plethora of other employee-engaging benefits,” says Combs-Orgeman.

Customer overpayment and credit card fraud

A supposed customer may overpay by check and ask you to return the difference or pay another party. Funds can appear available before the bank discovers the check is fraudulent. The FTC specifically cautions small businesses about this overpayment scam.³

“If your business pays with paper checks, definitely take advantage of one of our check fraud preventative solutions such as Positive Pay,” says Combs-Orgeman.

Contact your financial institution before returning money from a suspicious payment.

For online card payments, discuss fraud screening with your payment processor. Visa advises merchants to investigate discrepancies and seek further verification when an order remains suspicious despite authorization.⁴

Clarify with your payment processor the following:

  • How staff should hold suspicious orders
  • How they should verify customer details
  • How to retain any supporting records

Include refunds and disputes in that discussion.

Employee fraud and misuse of access

Hiring honest employees who will maintain control of your business bank accounts is critical. Adding background checks to your hiring process is a good business practice to help ensure you hire the right candidate to manage money.

Make independent review part of your workflow, even when you trust your staff. Review who can create vendors, approve expenses, issue refunds and change payroll records.

For refunds, ask the reviewer to inspect the original sale, the refund reason and the destination. For expense reimbursements, require supporting records and approval outside the claimant’s control.

Include your accounting team, who can separate cash handling from accounting responsibilities and independently review payroll changes.

Verify invoices and payment changes

Match invoices to purchasing records and confirm that the goods or services were received. Investigate duplicates and unfamiliar vendors before approval.

Handle a vendor's bank-account change

Require independent confirmation before updating any requested payment instructions. The FBI recommends verifying changes to account numbers or payment procedures directly with the requester.⁵ Of course, use independently established contact information, not details supplied in the suspicious activity.

As noted above, document the procedure so staff know what evidence to retain:

  • Whom they contacted
  • How they reached that person
  • What was confirmed.

Lastly, have the approver inspect that confirmation alongside the invoice. If confirmation fails, hold the payment and involve the person responsible for the vendor relationship. Don’t let an approaching due date become an informal exception to your rules.

Apply the rules to executives and payroll

Require urgent executive requests to follow the same approval process as other payments. Give employees an escalation route they can use without seeking permission from the person whose request they’re questioning.

Apply independent confirmation to requests received by phone or video, too. Make an established callback or approved internal channel part of the process; don’t make voice recognition the deciding factor.

For direct-deposit changes, contact the employee through established details. Separate permission to update payroll records from responsibility for reviewing those changes before payroll is released.

Separate duties and restrict access

Business fraud is less likely when more than one person signs off on business transactions. With dual control, two people are needed to authorize every banking activity, from cutting checks to receiving payments. To be clearer:

  • Dual control separates payment initiation from approval.
  • Separation of duties extends that separation across the workflow, including account reconciliation.

When combined with multi-factor authentication, you’ll add extra layers of security to protect your business from threats.

To succeed with this structure, avoid shared credentials. Give employees and outside providers access appropriate to their work, review permissions when responsibilities change, and remove access promptly when someone leaves.

Secure email, devices, and business information

Although outside hacking and large data breaches are much rarer than everyday check fraud when it comes to small businesses, it’s still crucial to safeguard your accounts and employee information by:

  • Using multi-factor authentication for banking, email and other sensitive systems
  • Maintaining strong, unique passwords (consider a password manager)
  • Keeping software updated

For smaller businesses, it’s also smart to dedicate one computer to banking only. With limited web history and no personal email or social media sign-ins, your network will be far less vulnerable to phishing scams because of that limited entry point.

Lastly, ask your IT provider to document who handles security alerts, access changes, software updates and recovery. Include outsourced systems in that discussion so responsibilities don’t fall between your staff and a provider.

Protect your small business identity and EIN

Protecting your business from fraud starts with protecting yourself. “If you end up needing a business loan and you’ve been a victim of personal identity theft, remember that your credit score is what’s used to determine your business lendability,” says Combs-Orgeman.

Safeguard your Employer Identification Number, tax records and banking information. The IRS identifies unexpected tax notices, duplicate filings and missing correspondence as possible signs of business identity theft. Consult its business identity theft guidance to identify the appropriate reporting process.

These are a few other measures you can take to protect your personal identity:

  • Use free credit monitoring applications.
  • Consider freezing your credit if you know you won’t apply for a credit card or loan soon.
  • Store your account login information in a secure place.
  • Store your personal and business checkbooks securely.

Train employees to pause and report

Employee awareness alone can help mitigate a wide variety of business email compromise scams, including phishing attacks, vendor billing fraud and cyber fraud. In fact, the FTC recommends training employees to recognize scams and encouraging them to discuss suspicious requests.¹

Ensure your employees have the digital and financial literacy to make safe, informed decisions by aligning training with their roles and providing a confidential reporting route that lets them raise concerns about a supervisor.

What to do if you suspect business fraud

Contact your bank while you’re gathering details. Don’t wait for a complete internal fraud investigation.

  • Use a verified bank contact. Ask whether the bank can stop or recover the payment and contact the receiving institution. Report business email compromise to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center.
  • Preserve evidence. Retain messages, invoices, payment instructions, transaction records and relevant logs. Coordinate with your IT provider to preserve evidence while securing affected systems. The FTC’s data-breach response guide emphasizes evidence preservation and coordinated containment.⁶
  • Assess notification obligations. If personal information was exposed, consult legal counsel about applicable notices. The FTC’s data-breach response guide explains that notification responsibilities depend on the circumstances and applicable law.⁶
  • Contact your insurance broker. Ask which policy, if any, may address the event, what notice is required and which documents to preserve.

If the event involved compromised email, ask your IT provider to investigate access and settings before you resume using that account for payment communications.

Choose fraud prevention services that fit your payments

Match banking controls to each account’s purpose. Associated Bank offers the following business fraud protection measures.

ServiceGeneral functionWhat to ask
Check Positive PayCompares presented checks with issued-check records.Which fields are checked, and how are issued records submitted?
Payee verificationAdds payee-name matching to check controls.Is it included, and how are name differences handled?
Reverse Positive PayProvides presented-check information for your team to review.What review workload and decision process will staff handle?
ACH Positive PayApplies authorization or review controls to incoming Automated Clearing House (ACH) debits.Which debits generate exceptions, and which can be approved through rules?
ACH filtersUses rules to allow or restrict incoming ACH debits.Who can change the rules, and how are changes approved?
Check Block or ACH BlockRestricts covered check or ACH activity.Can the account operate with those restrictions?

Learn more about what security products are best for your business or call the Associated Bank Business Care Team at 800-270-2707.

Key takeaways

  • Verify payment requests and changes. Independently confirm new vendor payment details, banking changes and unexpected transfer requests using trusted contact information to prevent fraudulent payments.

  • Separate financial responsibilities. Reduce internal fraud risk by assigning different people to prepare, approve and reconcile payments. Establish independent oversight, even in small businesses.

  • Strengthen account security. Use multifactor authentication, restrict access to sensitive financial systems and regularly review employee permissions to protect business information.

  • Monitor transactions and recognize warning signs. Set up banking alerts, reconcile accounts regularly and train employees to identify suspicious invoices, phishing attempts and unusual payment activity.

  • Explore fraud prevention tools with your bank. Services such as Check Positive Pay, ACH Positive Pay and payment filters can help identify unauthorized transactions when paired with strong internal controls.

  • Have a fraud response plan. If fraud is suspected, contact your bank immediately, preserve relevant records, secure compromised accounts and report the incident to the appropriate authorities.

  • Review and update fraud prevention procedures regularly. Work with your banker, accountant and IT provider to assess vulnerabilities, clarify responsibilities and ensure your fraud protection measures keep pace with your business.

How to Protect Your Business From Fraud Frequently Asked Questions

No. Check Positive Pay compares covered checks against issued records. ACH Positive Pay applies controls to covered ACH debits. These are payment-screening controls, not a substitute for verifying invoices and vendor relationships.

Ask your Business Banker to explain exclusions and your review responsibilities.

Don’t assume reimbursement. Ask your bank to explain the applicable account terms, service agreements and reporting requirements, and consider legal advice for a disputed loss.

Business accounts generally fall outside Regulation E’s protections for accounts established primarily for personal, family or household purposes. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Regulation E account definition establishes that distinction.

FDIC deposit insurance protects eligible deposits when an insured bank fails. It does not cover losses caused by fraud or theft, as the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency explains.

Ask your broker how the policy treats employee dishonesty, social engineering, computer fraud and funds-transfer fraud. Request policy-specific explanations of exclusions, deductibles, coverage limits, required controls and notification conditions.

Describe your actual payment process, including who verifies instructions and approves transfers. Ask the broker to walk through how a claim involving that process would be evaluated.



Sources
1. https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/new-study-finds-retailers-continue-to-contend-with-rising-levels-of-theft-and-violence
2. https://www.afponline.org/topics/payment-topics/payments-fraud
3. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/908a_scams_and_your_small_business_july_2023_508.pdf
4. https://usa.visa.com/support/small-business/fraud-protection.html
5. https://www.fbi.gov/how-we-can-help-you/common-frauds-and-scams/business-email-compromise
6. https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/data-breach-response-guide-business

Subscribe for more business insights
* = required field
⚠ Please fix the error in the form.

⚠ Enter your email address in the format: yourname@example.com

⚠ Please check the box that says 'I'm not a robot' before proceeding